8 Burning Questions About Sherlock’s Other Sibling – Answered

Ah, so she’s the East Wind?


You’ll no doubt remember the talk of “the East Wind” in ‘His Last Vow.’ Sherlock explained to John in that episode that Mycroft used to play a game with him when they were children – he told Sherlock a fairy tale of a monstrous East Wind which would come forth and pluck the unworthy from the earth. In one Mind Palace sequence, Mycroft gleefully tells Sherlock: “The East Wind is coming, Sherlock. It’s coming to get you.”

The last line of the episode also gathers a new meaning now. In response to Moriarty apparently being alive, John says: “Well, if he is, then he’d better wrap up warm. There’s an East Wind coming.” If only you knew, John…

This is a bit of conjecture on our part, but we imagine that Mycroft’s East Wind game came from him teasing Sherlock about their new baby sister. Perhaps Sherlock was feeling uneasy about having a new sibling, so Mycroft scared him further with a story about an East Wind – the meaning of their sister’s name – coming to get him.


But why was Mycroft calling her Sherrinford?


Yes, that’s a tricky one. Our best guess is that Sherrinford was the code name assigned to Euros. In ‘The Six Thatchers’, Mycroft assigns himself, Lady Smallwood, Sir Edwin and Vivan Norbury the codenames Antartica, Langdale, Ammo and Porlock during a top-secret briefing. We can assume that Euros’ turn to the dark side is a similarly hush-hush matter and so she is only referred to as Sherrinford.

As to why Mycroft was calling her – and what that “13th” post-in note on his fridge – was all about, we’ve no idea…


Is Euros working with Moriarty?


That’s the big question now. The suggestion at the end of this episode is that Euros was the one responsible for the “Miss Me” messages at the end of ‘His Last Vow.’ She did leave that same message for Sherlock in invisible ink on that sheet of paper. Just like Mary with her video, she might just have used Moriarty’s image to get Sherlock’s attention. Instead, “Miss me” refers to Sherlock missing his baby sister, not his arch-enemy.

On the other hand, we have been under the impression that Moriarty is returning for so long now that it would be a bit of a swizz if it turned out that Moffat and Gatiss were just playing us. Maybe we’ve another twist to come and Euros is working with Moriarty to bring her brother down? Maybe that’s why he has always been one step ahead of Sherlock – because he had someone who knew him since childhood on side?


So Tom Hiddleston isn’t involved, then?

Tom Hiddleston

Looks that way, sadly. It was always a long shot that the very busy actor would manage to find time to fit in Sherlock. 

That said, one line in ‘The Lying Detective’ caught our attention. When catching Smith’s confession, Sherlock says “why do people always stop at three?” – referring to the fact that people assume that things come in threes. This might not be the case, but this seemed to us to be a hint from Moffat that Euros is not the only extra Holmes sibling out there. We have assumed there are only three – but what if there are four of them? Perhaps Sherrinford isn’t a codename for Euros but is a separate sibling in themselves?

That’ll give you something to chew on for the next few days….


5 thoughts on “8 Burning Questions About Sherlock’s Other Sibling – Answered

  1. I’m not sure how much they wanted us to fall for the disguises because she was recognizable in every iteration. They got me on the reveal though. Didn’t see THAT coming!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I remember Mycroft saying “Put me through to Sherrinford, please”, doesn’t he? And then again “Sherrinford is secured”. That would imply it being a building etc. Well, Smallwood asks something like “Are you still talking with Sherrinford?” which sounds like a person so .. Dunno.


  3. I like your post above because I’ve also been pondering Euros since Sunday…

    I also have a few ideas to share about her and how she fits into the Holmes family dynamic. I personally think she’s actually in between Sherlock and Mycroft, instead of being the younger sibling. I feel the flashbacks Sherlock has had from his childhood in HLV, TST and TLD are back to an event involving Euros…when she wounded Redbeard and tried to kill Sherlock (…was Redbeard injured/killed trying to protect him?).

    Anyhoo, from this event she would have been institutionalized…Mycroft old enough to know all about it, but Sherlock being too young to remember. I was also thinking that Mycroft’s concern and protection for Sherlock is genuine…he knows what Euros is capable of doing.

    But when it comes to Sherrinford, I feel it’s the name of the institution where Euros was kept, instead of a name for a person. Mycroft never referred to it as a he/she, only as a proper noun.

    Finally, I love your idea that Euros has hooked up with Moriarty in some way…she’s getting revenge for the man she loved.

    Will any and all the above be wrong…probably!!

    Have I spent too much time thinking about…absolutely!!


  4. First of, I like to make my apoloies beforehand. I am from The Netherlands, so if my English is a bit of, That’s why!

    The problem I,m having a little bit at least, is that Sherlock didn’t recognized Euros. Not when she sat in front of him as Culverton Smith’s daughter, and not when she was John’s therapist. I mean, even if you haven’t seen someone for ages, surely it strange you don’t recognize your own sister?? Certainly not if you are Sherlock Holmes, the Master of deduction!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s